A simple holiday season and Pumpkin Bread. . .

My “Holidays” are the simplest of any I know. I made that choice 40 or so years ago. It suits me and I want to share what that looks like.

Because I come from a Catholic tradition, my celebration for this time of year is, basically, Christmas. But I resonate with the Solstice, so I celebrate both in quiet ceremonies at home. In the afternoon and evening I gather with family and friends. I adapt to the people around me and my geographical location at the moment, but simplicity is key.

I have one child. I collect things during the year that I think would make his life more wonderful. He is the only person on “my list” so anyone and anything beyond that is optional. Don’t get me wrong. I love giving and getting meaningful gifts . . . but “meaningful” is the operative word here. Everyone I know has more stuff than they want or need. I don’t feel obligated to contribute to their burden of stuff to take care of . . .  but if there is something I can give that is thoughtful and heartfelt and needed? . . . I’m all over it, though I usually deliver at any time during the year, when it’s really needed.

I do, however, have one little gift tradition . . . I make Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Bread for selected friends, family and acquaintances. It’s a tradition that started in the early 1970s with my next-door neighbor, Mrs. Shubel.

She was in her 80s and lived to the north of the first house I bought with my first husband.

first-house-2
My First House as a Grown Up

Mrs. Shubel taught me many things, but only two of them were life-changing:

  1. It’s a worthy thing to have a large, spectacular garden populated with one type of plant that blooms only 3 weeks a year (in her case it was bearded iris).
  2. It’s important to have a really good Holiday recipe to give as your signature gift.

Mrs. Shubel’s recipe was her Pumpkin Bread. She put dates in it and baked it in one-pound coffee cans. You couldn’t miss it. Who else delivered aromatic cylinders as presents?

But I don’t drink coffee that comes in cans and I’ve had years to play with her recipe. My adaptations settled in about 35 years ago to create my Signature Holiday Gift. I traded chocolate chips for dates and baked it in regular pans. And now I gift it to you. Put your name on it and call it your specialty. Use it to simplify your life . . .

MRS. SHUBEL’S  and CHERYL’S HOLIDAY PUMPKIN BREAD waiting for your signature. . .

First . . . it needs to be very cold and beautiful outside . . .
Christmas-Eve-Morn

Well . . . that’s not true . . . but this was the view the morning I started baking my 2009 Christmas bread. The winter sun here is rare and thus precious. I enjoy it at any . . . and every . . . opportunity.

Next, read or reread my earlier post about the basics of making any cake (or, in this case, a sweet bread which is the same process): The Zucchinis are Coming . . . Let them be Cake.

Then get out the recipe:Pumpkin-Bread-Recipe

The original recipe called for a small can of pumpkin which was about 2 cups at the time. Long ago I upped the recipe so that I could bake more at once and I use the larger can of pumpkin. I will give you both sets of numbers. The numbers in the brackets refer to the more ambitious amount.

DRY INGREDIENTS:

  • 3½ C flour [5¼ C]
  • 2 t baking soda [1 T]
  • ½ t baking powder [¾ t]
  • 1½ t salt [2¼ t]
  • 1 t cinnamon [1½ t]
  • ½ t [¾ t] each of ground cloves, ginger and nutmeg

Put all of these into a bowl

PB-dry-ingredand then gently whisk them together.

PB-dry-mixed-ingred

THE WET INGREDIENTS:

  • 2 C pumpkin (small can) [3 C] (most of a large can)
  • ⅔ C water [1 C]

Combine these in a separate bowl.

Pumpkin & Water

THE CREAM-TOGETHER INGREDIENTS:

  • 2 ⅔ C sugar [4 C]
  • ⅔ C butter [1 C]
  • 4 eggs [6 eggs]

THE CHUNKY ADDITIONS:

  • 1 C of  chopped dates OR raisins OR chocolate chips [1½ C]
  • 1 C of chopped walnuts [1½ C]

Start by beating the “cream-together” ingredients with an electric hand or stand mixer. You could even use a wooden spoon if that’s all you had but it’s a lot of work. Soften the butter first. It sat out at room temperature over night (but the room was pretty chilly).

Butter

Notice how it gets lighter in color as you incorporate air.Creamed-butter

Once it’s fluffy start adding the sugar about a cup at a time.Add-sugarand beat after each addition to incorporate the sugar evenly.Beat-in-sugar

Once the sugar is all in you can add the eggs, 2 at a time, and beat after each addition:Add-eggs (Notice the bright orange yoke versus the lighter yellow yolk of the larger egg in front. The bright orange yolk is from my friend’s chicken, the lighter one is store-bought.)
And now you have 3 bowls of ingredients: dry, wet and creamed.

Three-bowls

Some important notes here.

  1. Once you combine the baking soda and powder with liquid, you’re starting the chemical reaction that makes bubbles so you need to get it into a preheated oven (350º) in a hurry. That means your pans should already be prepared.
  2. When you were working with the butter, sugar and eggs, you beat the heck out of it to incorporate air. Now, you are going to stir gently . . . just enough to mix everything evenly. If you beat it, it will develop the gluten in the flour and it will be tough. That’s why we knead bread . . . to give it that chewy texture. However, you want your cakes and sweet breads to be tender and a little crumbly.

Let me back up a little here. My actual order of doing things is this:

  1. The night before baking I assemble the dry ingredients and take the butter and eggs out of the refrigerator and let them come to room temperature overnight.
  2. At baking time, before I start the mixing process I prepare the pans and turn on the oven.

THE BAKING PANS

Mrs. Shubel’s original recipe calls for 3 one-pound coffee cans half filled and baked at 350º for one hour. These are my adaptations:

Smaller recipe: 2 standard loaf pans (9″ x 5″ x 2¾”) OR 4 medium loaf pans (7½” x 3¾” x 2¼”) OR  one standard pan and 2 mediums.

Larger recipe: This is how I usually do it. I use my 4 medium pans plus 3 smaller ones (5½” x 3″ x 2″).

I’m trying to make this simple and I realize that not everyone has 4 sizes of loaf pans on hand, but this is the best I can do with honesty. If you are a novice baker and you like things like zucchini, pumpkin and banana bread, you need 2 standard loaf pans. That’s how I started. These kinds of breads freeze very well and it takes just as much effort to make one loaf as two, so make at least 2 at a time.

Regardless of the size of the  pans, this is how you prepare them.

  1. Grease them with Crisco or butter. That means to take a piece of paper towel or waxed paper, grab a small clump of solid fat with it and rub all the interior surfaces of the pans.
  2. Cut pieces of waxed paper (or baking parchment) the size of the bottoms of the pans.Waxed-paper-bottoms
  3. Once the pans are greased the paper clings easily to them.

Prepared-Pans4. How long you bake them depends on the size of your pans and your oven but I find that these pans need about 45 minutes of baking. You might need to take the smaller ones out of the oven earlier. Just keep testing by inserting a toothpick into the center of the loaf. If it comes out clean and not with goopy batter on it, they’re done.

26 Replies to “A simple holiday season and Pumpkin Bread. . .”

  1. Thanks for this great recipe. I will try it instead of my old one.We for this big pumpkin (zucca)that I roast in the oven then purée .That will make a lot of bread.You’re an inspiration Cheryl ,best wishes to you and a very Merry Christmas.
    Buon Natale

  2. Hi Cheryl. Glad you’re back and recovering.
    How much does a can of pumpkin weigh. I dont think I’ve ever seen canned pumpkin here in Australia.

    Thank you
    Kathleen

  3. Dear Cheryl,
    Thank you so much for the gift of the Pumpkin Bread recipe. What a lovely idea. I made my breads today using the dates and of course I had to try one. It is delicious!. Merry Christmas to you and yours and may 2018 be a Happy and Healthy one.

    1. Thank you for your kind wishes Margaret . . . and I’m delighted you made it with dates. Mrs. Shubel would be happy.

  4. Dear Cheryl,
    Thank you for sharing this recipe. It sounds delicious and I can’t wait to try it and share it! And I especially appreciate that it comes at a time when I can’t find one of my grandmother”s recipes that our family always shared at this time of year.
    Julie

  5. Dear Cheryl, How very thoughtful of you to share a special recipe of yours. Thank you…
    Wishing you a Christmas filled with love and a New Year of Peace and hope. xx

  6. Just popped my loaves in the oven. The batter sure is tasty! Can’t wait to taste the baked product later. Thank you for sharing the love & Happy Christmas to you, Cheryl!

  7. Merry Christmas from an Australian knitter who greatly values your contributions. What a lovely gift to us all is your Pumpkin Bread recipe.

    1. Thank you Peter. I love to share recipes. Then, when I misplace my old copy (which I have been known to do) I can always recover it from the internet. 🙂

  8. Cheryl, first and most of all Happy Holidays to you and yours. May 2017 be as peaceful and as joyful as only possible.
    Thank you for both recipes. I’ll try them both and report on my success?! If they are as good as your knitting advices, my family will have a blust. Now it all depends on my abilities…ooppss… 🙂

  9. Thanks Cheryl for sharing your wonderful recipes.I will definitely try and fit this one in,as I’m in a baking frenzy!Hope all goes well with your eye surgery and wish you and yours a wonderful,calm and cozy Christmas.

    1. Thank you Geri. It was a lovely Christmas and my eye is doing great . . . except now I can see dirt and dust that I never saw before. In my house.

  10. Spring is approaching rapidly as I am reading your article and recipe. You can bet I’m tucking it away for next fall. I love your approach of simplicity and life enriching gifts. I see we have something in common: we each have one child. Sons. <3

  11. I get a pumpkin every year in the fall and freeze it. I steam it slightly to soften it and make it easier to cut into chunks. I use it as a vegetable in winter, or make soup, or any baking. Love it! If you have half a cup left over, just dump it all in! It won’t make a difference. Or just add it to anything you are making that day — like soup. It’s a very versatile vegetable, and sadly under-rated.

  12. I freeze cooked apple — some on its own, and some with dates or sultanas or raisens added — in silicone muffin thingies. When frozen, the front pops out easily and straight into a large freezer bag. They don’t stick together much unless really squashed together before fully frozen. I eat them for breakfast (one minute in the microwave), or cook with them. The silicone forms are much better for freezing fruit than metal dishes, but I prefer metal ones for cooking muffins etc. I also freeze apricots and feijoas (not together). I’ve discovered that I don’t even need to cook those fruits before freezing.

  13. Hello Cheryl, I am baker and your recipe sounds intriging….
    but I do have a question….I buy the large cans of Libby, Libby, Libby
    Pumpkin….29 oz……3 1/2 cups………you do not use the entire can?
    I believe you said 3 cups……what to do with that 1/2 cup of leftover pumpkin?
    I cannot just discard it….just too frugal…hah thank you, Dana

    1. Hi Dana . . . I never throw out food if I can avoid it. I heat it up and eat it with butter, salt and pepper if I use canned. But usually I cook my own from Halloween pumpkins and mash it and freeze it in recipe amounts. I also often replace 1/2 C of the butter with 1/2 C of homemade applesauce, also frozen. I line muffin cups with clingy wrap, measure in the 1/2 C applesauce and freeze them. Then I pop them out, wrap all the way with the saran wrap and put those in a zip lock bag. We have apple trees around here.

      1. Cheryl, I love reading your emails and thank you for this recipe. It sounds like we both have the same attitude about not wasting foods and enjoyment of using fresh produce when it is in season. There are so many of us readers who would love to be your next door neighbor! Thanks also for the tremendous help you give to us aspiring knitters of the world.

    1. Even better Mary Jane. You can make oodles of them and put them in the freezer. And thanks for the “sweet” comment. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *